Head-to-head
CaptivateIQ vs Xactly Forecast: which one in 2026?
CaptivateIQ is a per-seat commission platform built around the SmartGrid calculation engine, and Xactly sells its Incent product in three tiers called Core, Plus and Ultimate. Both hide prices. CaptivateIQ prints more about audits and hosting; Xactly prints a clearer map of what each tier adds.
Verdict
CaptivateIQ is the safer pick when a security review comes first, because its audit and hosting statements are specific. Xactly is easier to scope, since the tiers say what is added and where ASC 606 and AI Agents begin. Both withhold prices and offer no trial, so ask each for a quote covering the same payee count, the compliance items you need and written answers on AI data use, which neither page covered.
CaptivateIQ and Xactly Forecast side by side
| CaptivateIQ | Xactly Forecast | |
|---|---|---|
| Price entry | Quoted | Quoted |
| What you are quoted | A per-seat subscription counting admins and payees, plus a one-time setup charge whose amount the pricing page does not give. | One of three Incent tiers, with price tied to the number of people paid and the complexity of the plans. |
| Tier clarity | No plan names are published, so scope is settled in a sales conversation after a product tour. | Core, Plus and Ultimate each list what they add, which lets a buyer scope the suite before any call. |
| Revenue recognition | ASC 606 reporting is its own add-on subscription, with optional one-time implementation help billed alongside it. | ASC 606 compliance and prior period processing arrive with Plus, so they are bundled rather than billed on a separate line. |
| AI on offer | Catalyst models plan changes with predictive machine learning, and AI Agents appear under the label Assist without a described task list. | AI Assistants come with Core, while AI Agents, proactive insights and Xactly Intelligence start at Ultimate. |
| Testing changes | Catalyst is the layer for trying pay design changes before they reach reps, and managed services come in three support tiers. | A full sandbox sits in Plus, separating test work from production, with business group security limiting visibility between units. |
| Reps and managers | Reporting is included in the subscription, so payout and accrual summaries need no separate analytics purchase. | Dashboards show reps and managers attainment and earnings, built to cut the statement questions reaching sales operations. |
| Security detail | Annual SOC 1 and SOC 2 audits are stated, reports can be requested, and hosting is AWS with encrypted backups in a US region. | The trust page read named no certifications, hosting region or retention period, so a security package has to be requested. |
| Connectors named | The pricing page describes integrations generically, so whether HubSpot, NetSuite or Workday connect natively must be asked. | Salesforce, Microsoft, Workday and HubSpot are named, with standard connectors in Core and advanced ones in Plus. |
Where each one wins
CaptivateIQ wins on
- Prints annual SOC 1 and SOC 2 audits with reports on request, where Xactly's trust page named none.
- Includes reporting in the subscription and offers managed services in three support tiers for thin sales operations teams.
- Catalyst gives a named modeling layer with predictive machine learning at the platform level, not only at a top tier.
Xactly Forecast wins on
- Lays out what each tier adds, so a buyer can scope Core, Plus or Ultimate before any sales call.
- Bundles ASC 606 compliance and a full sandbox in Plus instead of selling revenue recognition as a separate add-on.
- Names Salesforce, Microsoft, Workday and HubSpot as integrations, where CaptivateIQ names none.
Which to pick
Pick CaptivateIQ if
Your finance team wants audited security reports, a spreadsheet-style calculation grid and managed services, and is happy to negotiate seats and setup in one quote.
Pick Xactly Forecast if
You need a tier map you can read in advance, ASC 606 and a sandbox in one step, and named CRM and HR connectors.
Each tool in context: CaptivateIQ profile, Xactly Forecast profile, and the full Best AI Sales Commission Software in 2026.
Frequently asked questions
Which one charges extra for ASC 606?
CaptivateIQ sells ASC 606 reporting as its own add-on subscription, with optional one-time implementation help. Xactly puts ASC 606 compliance and prior period processing into the Plus tier. Neither publishes an amount, so include that line in each request for quotes so the totals can be compared fairly.
Can I try CaptivateIQ or Xactly before buying?
Neither pricing page offers a trial. CaptivateIQ points buyers to a product tour and a sales conversation, and Xactly offers a tailored demo. Testing the engine on real plans would need a vendor-led proof of concept, which neither page describes.
Which vendor states more about security?
CaptivateIQ's security page states annual SOC 1 and SOC 2 audits with reports on request, plus AWS hosting with US backups. The Xactly trust page read named no certifications, hosting region or retention period, so request its security package early.
Where do AI Agents start in each product?
Xactly lists AI Assistants in Core and AI Agents with proactive insights in Ultimate. CaptivateIQ names AI Agents under the label Assist and Catalyst for modeling, but the pages read give no tier gate, task list or accuracy detail, so confirm all three in a demo.