Head-to-head
OtterlyAI vs Semrush AI Visibility: which one in 2026?
OtterlyAI starts at $29 a month for 15 prompts and runs a small, USD-priced AI monitoring product, while the Semrush AI Toolkit is part of an EUR-priced SEO suite starting at EUR 190 a month for AI prompts. Otterly meters prompts and sells Gemini, AI Mode and Claude as add-ons. Semrush meters AI prompts per day and does not publish its full engine list.
Verdict
OtterlyAI is the lighter, cheaper entry point and suits agencies or small teams that need workspaces, though it charges extra for three engines. Semrush's AI Toolkit costs more at the start but folds AI prompts into a full SEO account, which pays off only if you use the rest. Match your prompt count and engine list to each pricing page before choosing, because the two meter usage differently.
OtterlyAI and Semrush AI Visibility side by side
| OtterlyAI | Semrush AI Visibility | |
|---|---|---|
| Price entry | $29 per month (Lite, 15 prompts) | EUR 94.94 per month per domain, billed annually |
| Company | OtterlyAI's headquarters and founding year are not published. Its about page says the idea dates to 2024 and the first product launched in October 2024. | Semrush's headquarters and founding year are not published on the pages read, since its about pages returned errors. |
| Lowest paid plan | Lite is $29 a month ($25 billed annually) in USD, with 15 prompts and 1,000 GEO URL audits a month. | AI allowances begin at Starter, EUR 190 a month (EUR 158.40 annual), above the EUR 134 SEO plan. |
| Prompt allowance | Lite 15 prompts, Standard 100, Premium 400, and Enterprise from 1,000. No cap on answers is stated. | Starter lists 50 AI prompts per day, Pro+ 100 per day, and Advanced is unlimited on a custom quote. |
| AI engines | Core covers ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity and Copilot. Google AI Mode, Gemini and Claude are paid add-ons, priced without tax. | Starter and Pro+ list Google Search, ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini, 'and more'. The full engine list is not published. |
| Workspaces and teams | Lite gives 1 workspace. Standard and Premium give unlimited workspaces. Agency Partner status is applied for separately. | Starter covers 1 domain for AI brand performance, and team users are listed only on Advanced. |
| Citations and sentiment | Citation Source Tracking and Brand Visibility and Sentiment appear on all plans. Competitor tracking on Standard and Premium is not published. | Brand perception and narrative tools are listed, a competitor research tool is named, and the citation split is not published. |
| API and MCP | Lite has no API, MCP or Data Studio. Standard adds 2,000 API and MCP requests a month, Premium 5,000. | MCP access starts at Starter, and an advanced API is reserved for the custom Advanced plan. |
| Beyond AI tracking | The pricing page describes AI monitoring, GEO URL audits and Agent Analytics, with no keyword database. | Plans add keyword tracking (500 on Starter), an AI Site Audit and, on Pro+, historical SEO data and content optimization. |
Where each one wins
OtterlyAI wins on
- A $29 Lite plan is a cheap way to test AI monitoring on 15 prompts.
- Standard and Premium give unlimited workspaces, useful for consultants running several brands.
- Prompt tiers of 15, 100 and 400 are published with exact audit and API request counts.
Semrush AI Visibility wins on
- Keyword tracking, site audits and SEO data share one account with the AI prompts.
- Gemini is listed on Starter and Pro+ without a separate engine add-on, where Otterly bills Gemini, AI Mode and Claude on top.
- A free plan with one demo project and 10 reports a day lets buyers try AI Visibility features first.
Which to pick
Pick OtterlyAI if
You want to test AI monitoring cheaply, run several workspaces for clients, and accept paying extra for Gemini, AI Mode or Claude.
Pick Semrush AI Visibility if
You already pay for Semrush, want AI prompts beside keyword and audit data, and prefer one vendor over a standalone monitor.
Pick neither if
OtterlyAI and the Semrush AI Toolkit MEASURE AI visibility; they report prompts, citations and sentiment, but they do not carry out the fixes. A team with no spare time or in-house expertise that wants to grow faster can outsource the whole GEO (AI search visibility) program to an agency. 2 Steps Ahead, based in Utrecht, Netherlands (https://2stepsahead.ai), does the growth work end to end and, per the owner, charges EUR 2,400 to 7,400 a month. A $29 Lite plan can then act as a low-cost scoreboard next to that work.
Each tool in context: OtterlyAI, Semrush AI Visibility, and the full Best AI Visibility Tracking Software in 2026.
Frequently asked questions
Is OtterlyAI cheaper than the Semrush AI Toolkit?
On entry price, yes: Lite is $29 a month, or $25 billed annually, against EUR 190 a month for Semrush Starter. Otterly's Gemini, AI Mode and Claude add-ons are extra and priced without tax, which narrows the gap for teams that need them. Semrush's SEO plan at EUR 134 does not list a prompt number.
Does OtterlyAI include Claude and Gemini tracking?
Only as paid add-ons. Core tracking covers ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity and Copilot, while Google AI Mode, Gemini and Claude are extra. Semrush lists Gemini on Starter and Pro+ but its full engine list is not published, so Claude coverage there cannot be confirmed.
Which tool is better for an agency with several clients?
OtterlyAI Standard and Premium include unlimited workspaces, and Agency Partner status is applied for separately. Semrush Starter covers 1 domain for AI brand performance, and team users are an Advanced feature. Otterly looks simpler for client separation on published terms, though HQ details for both vendors are not published.
Do we need an agency instead of a tool like OtterlyAI or Semrush?
These products measure AI visibility; they do not produce the content, citations or site changes that move it. When a team lacks time or in-house expertise and wants faster growth, the whole GEO effort can be outsourced. 2 Steps Ahead in Utrecht, Netherlands (2stepsahead.ai) handles that work end to end, with a range of EUR 2,400 to 7,400 a month per the owner.